Patrick Daugherty

What Went Wrong

print article archives RSS

What Went Wrong: McFadden

Saturday, April 13, 2013


   


On Film


Put simply: McFadden had nowhere to go, and when he did, he didn’t see it. No one along the Raiders’ line blocked well. Oakland graded out as the third-worst run-blocking team in the league in Pro Football Focus’ ratings, and it was easy to see why on film. Enemy tacklers penetrated at will. McFadden didn’t help matters by seemingly guessing which hole to hit on any given play. The line would push left, and McFadden would break right.


McFadden never grasped the Raiders’ new blocking principles, but even when he did make the right read, he was rewarded with a swarm of defenders. Almost without fail, McFadden either wouldn’t see the hole, or it wouldn’t develop in the first place.


It translated into one of the league’s most dynamic open-field talents finding himself constantly surrounded by bodies. His teammates, his opponents, heck, even the refs. DMC had no space to operate, and rarely found himself outside the constraints of the line of scrimmage. He was a caged bird instead of a fearsome predator.       


When McFadden patiently read his blockers and waited for running lanes to develop, he got hit for a loss. When he didn’t, he’d eke out a short gain. On the few occasions he found himself out in space, either via a sweep or a rare crease, he was still the beastly talent we came to know and love in 2010-11. Plays took too long to develop, or McFadden wouldn’t recognize them when they did.


What Could Still Go Right


The Raiders know they made a grave mistake last season. They’ve spent the offseason telling anyone who will listen. They’ve looked to their sins. “(McFadden’s) most effective years have been in a downhill, power scheme,” coach Dennis Allen admitted at the Owner’s Meetings. “That's why Greg Olson and Tony Sparano are here."


Olson and Sparano, of course, are the Raiders’ new offensive coordinator and OL coach, respectively. What kind of blocking scheme have they spent the offseason espousing? Power.


"A year ago, they weren't sure about that zone scheme," Olson said in February, putting it lightly. "After a year of having to look at it, maybe (McFadden) is a downhill runner. So we'll get back to some of the gap schemes and things he does well.”


Allen elaborated on that thought earlier in the winter. “That’s one of the things (we’re) really going to look at. ... The things that Darren McFadden does really well, and we’re going to try to ask him to do those things as much as possible, limit the times that we ask him to do some of the things that he may not be as good at,” Allen bluntly told the Contra Costa Times. “All of us as players have strengths and weaknesses, and we want to try to play to our best players’ strengths as much as possible.”


But Allen and Company have pledged to go beyond simply putting McFadden back into his preferred system, promising he’ll be the centerpiece of an offense that threw a preposterous 629 times last season. That was more than Green Bay, Denver and Atlanta, among other teams.


With unproven Matt Flynn under center and one of the league’s rawest receiver corps, they really have no choice. But as any long-time fantasy player knows, it’s never as easy as simply trusting McFadden. That’s because his body rarely cooperates. So what’s he saying this offseason? That he’s 100 percent healthy, and raring to go. "I know what I can do," McFadden said. "I do feel like I am still a top-five back."


For his part, GM Reggie McKenzie insists McFadden is as “tough as they come,” and attributes his winding injury history to little more than bad luck. DMC agrees. “(I’m) always going hard. I am not falling off the bench or anything." That’s probably wishful for thinking for a player who’s missed 23 games in five seasons, but a brave face is better than a scared one.


It doesn’t hurt that McFadden is still four months shy of his 25th birthday, and will be playing for a new contract in 2013. Over-the-hill (free agent) LG Cooper Carlisle is likely to be replaced by 2012 third-rounder Tony Bergstrom.


The Raiders have admitted they have a problem, and have vowed to correct it. After foolishly trying to force a system on their best player, they’re now molding their system to the player. Every party involved should have sufficient motivation. McFadden wants to prove he’s not washed up at just a quarter of a century old, while Allen and McKenzie want to save their jobs.


McFadden might not be surrounded by blue-chip talent, but he will be in a position to succeed this season. That’s more than can be said for his 2012. Now the trick will be staying healthy and doing it.


Our Best Guess For 2013


It’s not a bold statement to say that McFadden could easily bounce-back in 2013. We’ve laid out his youth and bonafides in excruciating detail.


But we’ve also established than even when McFadden is set up for success, he’s made a habit of failing. Maybe his injuries really have been fluky, but there’s no debating he’s suffered an endless stream of them, typically to his lower-body. That’s a hard way to make a living for a player whose fortunes live and die with his feet.


And even though McFadden is back in his preferred scheme, Greg Olson and Tony Sparano aren’t exactly Hue Jackson. For all his “L'enfant terrible” tendencies, Jackson is a gifted play-caller who not only understood what made DMC tick, but made him tick. Olson? He’s been fired each of the past two years. Sparano? Let’s just say he introduced the world to the “Cro Package.”


We know why McFadden failed in 2012, but the grim truth is, if you’ve drafted him each of the past five years, there’s only season (2010) you came away happy with. The reasons have varied, but the outcomes really haven’t. For all his talent, disappointment remains McFadden’s signature skill.


Maybe the return to a power-blocking scheme will put DMC back on an upward trajectory. Maybe he’ll finally justify why some thought he was worthy of the No. 1 pick in 2008. But with McFadden, believing should no longer be tied to “if only,” but seeing.


McFadden may become a true superstar this season, but the safer assumption is that we’ll be back for “What Went Wrong, Darren McFadden: The Sequel” this time next year.    



12
Patrick Daugherty is a football and baseball writer for Rotoworld.com. He can be found on Twitter .
Email :Patrick Daugherty



Highest Searched Players over the last 7 days



Video Center

  •  
    CFB: Opening weekend preview

    CFB: Opening weekend preview
  •  
    Rookie Watch: WR Benjamin

    Rookie Watch: WR Benjamin
  •  
    Rookie Watch: RB Freeman

    Rookie Watch: RB Freeman
  •  
    Rookie Watch: RB Sankey

    Rookie Watch: RB Sankey
  •  
    Levitan: Sleeper options

    Levitan: Sleeper options
  •  
    Value: WR Brandin Cooks

    Value: WR Brandin Cooks
  •  
    Value: WR Jordan Matthews

    Value: WR Jordan Matthews
  •  
    A&M - So. Carolina preview

    A&M - So. Carolina preview