Evan Silva

NFL Draft Grades

print article archives RSS

Draft 2014: AFC Draft Grades

Monday, May 12, 2014



Kansas City Chiefs

23. Dee Ford, outside linebacker, Auburn.
87. Phillip Gaines, cornerback, Rice.
124. De'Anthony Thomas, offensive weapon, Oregon.
163. Aaron Murray, quarterback, Georgia.
193. Zach Fulton, guard, Tennessee.
200. Laurent Duvernay-Tardif, McGill (Canada).

Overview: The Chiefs entered the draft without a second-round pick after the 2013 Alex Smith trade. That deal has so far gone well for Kansas City, and is factored into the team's grade. Observers who don't really know how the NFL works panned the Ford pick because "they already have Tamba Hali and Justin Houston," failing to recall that DC Bob Sutton's defense tanked when Hali and Houston got hurt last year. The NFL season is a battle of attrition, and the Chiefs were painfully thin on edge rushers. Hali also may be in his final year with the club. Gaines offers a No. 1-corner ceiling in round three. I also think Fulton has a future at right guard, where Kansas City lost Geoff Schwartz and Jon Asamoah in free agency. Duvernay-Tardif is an intriguing prospect from a measurables standpoint. I'm not a fan of Murray or Thomas, though I realize they are big-name players. Thomas reminds of a softer, poor man's Dexter McCluster. Murray has been deemed "the next Drew Brees" by some. If Murray's career follows the path of all the QBs deemed "the next Drew Brees" in recent drafts, he isn't going to do much of anything in the NFL.

Grade: C+

Miami Dolphins

19. Ja'Wuan James, tackle, Tennessee.
63. Jarvis Landry, wide receiver, LSU.
67. Billy Turner, tackle/guard, North Dakota State.
125. Walt Aikens, cornerback, Liberty.
155. Arthur Lynch, tight end, Georgia.
171. Jordan Tripp, linebacker, Montana.
190. Matt Hazel, wide receiver, Coastal Carolina.
234. Terrence Fede, defensive end, Marist.

Overview: The James pick is perceived as a reach because most pre-draft mocks didn't have James in the top 32, but the Dolphins had a first-round grade on him. So I can't kill the pick. Their evaluators liked what they saw. It isn't like they took a guy they gave a day-two grade at 19. James needs to improve as a run blocker, but will solidify Ryan Tannehill's strong-side protection. Pass pro was a huge problem for last year's Fins. Landry is a stick-moving Hines Ward clone. A mauling college run blocker, Turner has every tool necessary to become a quality pass protector. My guess is Miami will start James at right tackle and Turner at right guard. Pairing rookie offensive linemen side by side worked out well for the 2013 Bears, who ranked No. 2 in the NFL in scoring. Aikens is a big, long press cornerback who could push for playing time quickly. The Lynch and Hazel picks I didn't like as much. The former doesn't do anything particularly well and the latter is a low-ceiling slot prospect. Tripp will immediately help on special teams and could develop into a starting weak-side linebacker down the road. Small-schooler Fede was worth the seventh-round stab. Rookie GM Dennis Hickey plugged holes and plucked value, for the most part. There wasn't a lot of flash and pizzazz, but I think the Dolphins got at least four good players.

Grade: B

New England Patriots

29. Dominique Easley, defensive tackle, Florida.
62. Jimmy Garoppolo, quarterback, Eastern Illinois.
105. Bryan Stork, center, Florida State.
130. James White, running back, Wisconsin.
140. Cameron Fleming, tackle, Stanford.
179. Jon Halapio, guard, Florida.
198. Zach Moore, defensive end, Concordia.
206. Jemea Thomas, defensive back, Georgia Tech.
244. Jeremy Gallon, wide receiver, Michigan.

Overview: I didn't like this draft. Easley is a cat-quick penetrator with major medical red flags. He's a boom-or-bust prospect after suffering two college ACL tears. I don't think Garoppolo has the pocket presence to succeed as an NFL starter. His arm strength and small hands are also concerns. Stork, Fleming, and Halapio were good college players, but are painfully short on athleticism. I realize the Patriots are becoming a power football team, but offensive linemen still need to be able to move. White is a low-ceiling tailback pick who does some things well (pass protect, ball security). He projects strictly as a role player. D-2 product Moore has down-the-road potential, but may not contribute until after Tom Brady's "window" closes. I thought versatile Thomas brought good late-round value, but Gallon will prove a throwaway pick. The tide of this draft could turn if Easley stays off the trainer's table, and one or two of the O-Linemen becomes an exceptional run blocker. I'm just not optimistic. I was also disappointed the Patriots did not use an early-round selection on a tight end. Perhaps they'll sign Jermichael Finley or Dustin Keller.

Grade: C-

New York Jets

18. Calvin Pryor, safety, Louisville.
49. Jace Amaro, tight end, Texas Tech.
80. Dexter McDougle, cornerback, Maryland.
104. Jalen Saunders, return specialist, Oklahoma.
115. Shaq Evans, wide receiver, UCLA.
137. Dakota Dozier, guard, Furman.
154. Jeremiah George, linebacker, Iowa State.
195. Brandon Dixon, cornerback, NW Missouri State.
209. Quincy Enunwa, wide receiver, Nebraska.
210. IK Enemkpali, outside linebacker, Louisiana Tech.
213. Tajh Boyd, quarterback, Clemson.
233. Trevor Reilly, outside linebacker, Utah.

Overview: GM John Idzik's second-ever draft was a true meat-and-potatoes effort. Top pick Pryor is an extremely physical, energetic presence and a rich man's T.J. Ward. Fans wanted Idzik to draft a small, speedy wideout, but Amaro is a superior team fit as a movement tight end with a huge catch radius (34-inch arms). 6-foot-3 Eric Decker and 6-foot-5 Amaro will be Geno Smith's (or Michael Vick's) go-to guys. McDougle runs 4.47 and would've been a higher pick if not for a senior-year injury. Evans and Enunwa are big, physical possession receivers with red-zone chops. Dozier profiles as a future starting guard. George is an intriguing nickel 'backer prospect and will contribute early on special teams. The picks I disliked were Saunders, whom I don't expect will help beyond punt returns, and Reilly, a 26-year-old who beat up on 19-year-old Pac 12 offensive linemen for his production. Boyd's stock dropped dramatically as a senior, but he has enough athleticism and arm strength to warrant the late-round flier. I don't think the Jets will be competing for Super Bowls until they establish a quarterback solution, but I expect them to continue to be competitive every week. And I think their roster got much stronger with this draft.

Grade: B+

Oakland Raiders

5. Khalil Mack, linebacker/end, Buffalo.
36. Derek Carr, quarterback, Fresno State.
81. Gabe Jackson, guard, Mississippi State.
107. Justin Ellis, defensive tackle, Louisiana Tech.
116. Keith McGill, cornerback, Utah.
219. Travis Carrie, cornerback, Ohio.
235. Shelby Harris, defensive tackle, Illinois State.
247. Jonathan Dowling, safety, Western Kentucky.

Overview: I've been down on GM Reggie McKenzie ever since he traded for Matt Flynn, but it is a haul like this one that can change opinions. Oakland entered this draft lacking both a franchise quarterback and franchise pass rusher. McKenzie obtained the latter by staying true to his board at the fifth pick. Mack is a relentless, violent outside-edge rusher offensive coordinators will have to scheme specifically to stop. Carr's struggles in muddied pockets are a big concern -- and the reason he wasn't a first-round pick -- but his arm strength and athleticism were every bit worth grabbing toward the top of round two. I expect Jackson to start at left guard as a rookie, upgrading on Khalif Barnes. Fourth-rounder Ellis is a 334-pound space eater with plus movement. McGill and Carrie are classic press-corner prospects, at least one of whom I would bet becomes an NFL starter. I thought McKenzie knocked it out of the park right down to the seventh round, where Dowling is a rangy, long-armed, 6-foot-3 and 190-pound safety with 4.52 wheels. He could prove to be Charles Woodson's heir apparent. I'm giving this draft a B+ only because my view of Carr is pessimistic. If Carr does reach his ceiling, McKenzie will have plucked an A+ draft.


Grade: B+

Pittsburgh Steelers

15. Ryan Shazier, linebacker, Ohio State.
46. Stephon Tuitt, defensive end, Notre Dame.
97. Dri Archer, offensive weapon, Kent State.
118. Martavis Bryant, wide receiver, Clemson.
157. Shaquille Richardson, cornerback, Arizona.
174. Wesley Johnson, guard/center, Vanderbilt.
192. Jordan Zumwalt, linebacker, UCLA.
215. Daniel McCullers, defensive lineman, Tennessee.
230. Rob Blanchflower, tight end, Massachusetts.

Overview: Kevin Colbert has generally been an underwhelming drafter since taking over the Steelers' football operations. I thought he did pretty well here, despite pleas from his fanbase to select a cornerback in round one. In the early to middle rounds, at least, Colbert placed an emphasis on athleticism, a trait Pittsburgh has sorely lacked in recent years, particularly on defense. The only pick I didn't like was Archer, a severely undersized scatback type who, despite impressive straight-line speed, faces long odds of becoming an impact offensive player. Shazier and Tuitt add youth and upside to Dick LeBeau's unit. Richardson fell due to some off-field concerns, but is physically gifted enough to become Ike Taylor's replacement if nurtured properly. Bryant was a one-trick-pony deep threat at Clemson, but his size is needed in Pittsburgh's red-zone offense, and he can lift the lid off NFL defenses. Johnson may not play before 2015, but is a fit for OC Todd Haley's zone scheme. Zumwalt is a relentless overachiever. McCullers is probably just a big body, but worth the late stab. Colbert injected energy into his roster with this draft.

Grade: B

San Diego Chargers

25. Jason Verrett, cornerback, TCU.
50. Jeremiah Attaochu, linebacker/end, Georgia Tech.
89. Chris Watt, guard, Notre Dame.
165. Ryan Carrethers, nose tackle, Arkansas State.
201. Marion Grice, running back, Arizona State.
240. Tevin Reese, wide receiver, Baylor.

Overview: Tom Telesco's second draft as Chargers GM began by addressing (easily) his top need with Verrett, a physical slot corner who plays the ball well enough in the air to be functional outside. I loved the Attaochu pick. A high-upside 21-year-old who left Georgia Tech as the Yellow Jackets' all-time leader in sacks and tackles for loss, Attaochu will replace Dwight Freeney opposite Melvin Ingram no later than 2015. Watt is a limited athlete, but Telesco hit a home run with a "limited athlete" lineman last April, landing mauler RT D.J. Fluker. Fluker is going to be a long-term NFL star, and Watt could soon join him in the starting lineup with RG Jeromey Clary's contract expiring after 2014. Carrethers is a fire-hydrant space eater. Grice was a sixth-round luxury pick who will be hard pressed to make the roster barring a training-camp injury to Ryan Mathews, Danny Woodhead, or Donald Brown. Reese is explosive, but weighs 163 pounds. He'll have to learn to play special teams quickly to make the 53. Odds are, Telesco secured four contributing players. It's hard to be blown away by any six-person draft, but Telesco did a nice job.


Grade: C+

Tennessee Titans

11. Taylor Lewan, tackle, Michigan.
54. Bishop Sankey, running back, Washington.
112. DaQuan Jones, nose tackle, Penn State.
122. Marqueston Huff, defensive back, Wyoming.
151. Avery Williamson, inside linebacker, Kentucky.
178. Zach Mettenberger, quarterback, LSU.

Overview: The most perplexing draft in the league began on day one, where the fallout from GM Ruston Webster's first-round pick will likely either involve moving on from Tennessee's best offensive player (incumbent LT Michael Roos), or relegating its top free agent signing (RT Michael Oher) into a reserve role, where Oher would become the highest paid "swing" tackle in NFL history. Sankey's measurables look good on a spreadsheet and he'll have a boatload of fantasy football opportunity in Nashville, but his tape is Vick Ballard-like, and not indicative of a second-round pick. The best value picks were Jones, a lane-clogging nose who fills a glaring need in Ray Horton's 3-4, and Mettenberger, a cement-footed but big-armed passer with more negatives than positives. It's conceivable that half of Tennessee's six-man draft will wash out of the league before their rookie deals expire. The Titans have struggled to identify talent throughout Webster's tenure. I fully expect them to bring up the rear in the NFL's weakest division this year.

Grade: D



12
Evan Silva is a senior football editor for Rotoworld.com. He can be found on Twitter .
Email :Evan Silva



Highest Searched Players over the last 7 days



Video Center

  •  
    Braxton Miller NFL projection

    Braxton Miller NFL projection
  •  
    Levitan: Cameron vs. Witten

    Levitan: Cameron vs. Witten
  •  
    Levitan: Gerhart vs. Morris?

    Levitan: Gerhart vs. Morris?
  •  
    Levitan: Romo vs. Brady?

    Levitan: Romo vs. Brady?
  •  
    Levitan: Murray or Foster?

    Levitan: Murray or Foster?
  •  
    Levitan: Stacy or Ellington?

    Levitan: Stacy or Ellington?
  •  
    Levitan: A.J. Green or Dez?

    Levitan: A.J. Green or Dez?
  •  
    Levitan: Draft Ball or Bell?

    Levitan: Draft Ball or Bell?