Our final installment of post-draft dynasty rankings will cover the tight end position.
Back in 2008, 18.9 percent of league-wide targets were directed at a player listed as a tight end. This past season, the mark was up to 20.3 percent. That may not seem like a huge boost, but had that increase not occurred, a total of 530 targets would’ve been lost by tight ends during the 2013 season. Note that tight end targets were actually down in 2013 from 21.3 percent in 2012.
In fantasy circles, the increase in usage of tight ends as pass catchers over the years has added depth to the position, but there are still a handful of superstars who stand above the rest. Today we’ll take an in-depth look at those top options.
Note: Non-PPR scoring is assumed. Each player age listed is as of September 1, 2014, which falls just prior to Week 1 of the upcoming season. The draft year and round is also shown for each player.
Click it here for quarterback, running back, and wide receiver rankings.
Last season, Jimmy Graham saw 22 more targets, caught four more balls, had 368 more receiving yards, and scored three more touchdowns than the second place tight end in each category. Yeah, he’s the top tight end in dynasty. Powered by 16 touchdowns, Graham scored 54.5 more fantasy points than No. 2-ranked Vernon Davis. He has finished in the Top 2 at the position three years in a row. Graham is only 27 and, although he’s on a one-year deal in New Orleans, it’s hard to see them letting their top receiver get away. Currently in his prime and working out of one of the league’s top-scoring offenses with an elite quarterback, Graham should be one of the first overall players off the board on draft day.
Rob Gronkowski is nearly two and a half years younger than Graham and probably more of a dominant fantasy force when active. But constant injury woes make him in inferior dynasty asset. Gronkowski was No. 2 in fantasy points per game last season, but was active for only seven games. Over the last three seasons (including the playoffs), he has an absurd 36 touchdowns in 38 games. Gronkowski is so good that he’s worth picking in the early rounds even if you think he’ll miss a few games each season. Of course, he’ll need to do better than the nine games per season he’s averaging over the last two years. Gronkowski is only 25 and one of the most dominant players in the game. Savvy owners should be looking to buy low before the window closes early next season.
Our next tier is slightly deeper than our first. None of these five tight ends are over the age of 25 as of today’s date. This is a testament to the depth of young, emerging receiving talent at the position. After Graham and Gronkowski, it makes sense to wait a while at the position. There’s plenty of value to be had.
Julius Thomas was a breakout sensation in 2013, vaulting his way from “intriguing athlete” to dynasty superstar. Powered by Peyton Manning and Denver’s record-setting offense, Thomas caught 12 touchdowns in 14 games en route to a No. 4 finish in fantasy points at the position. The ex-basketball player (but of course) is only 25 and has at least another year or two with Manning tossing him the ball.
Like Thomas, Jordan Cameron is an ex-basketball player who was drafted in the fourth round of the 2011 draft and broke out in a big way last season. Cameron is two months younger than Thomas, but is slightly inferior a dynasty prospect only because he doesn’t have Manning on his side. In 2013, Cameron was No. 5 in fantasy scoring among tight ends, racking up 80 receptions for 917 yards and seven touchdowns. He was nothing short of elite in terms of converting targets into receptions. With Josh Gordon facing off-the-field issues, Cameron could easily lead Cleveland in targets this upcoming season.
Unless injury strikes, Tyler Eifert’s dynasty value is currently the lowest it will be for a very long time. A first-round pick one year ago, it’s no surprise that Eifert’s career is off to a slow start with Jermaine Gresham still on the roster. Gresham will be back in 2014, but Eifert figures to move past him at some point this year. Eifert is only 23 and has massive upside as a pass-catcher. Don’t overlook him.
The tenth overall pick in May’s draft, Eric Ebron has the size and receiving skills to produce at a TE1 level over the next decade. Landing in Detroit only helps his prospects. Brandon Pettigrew will surely lower Ebron’s short-term ceiling, but the team is wide receiver deficient, which will allow the rookie to step right into a prominent role in passing downs. Ebron isn’t a finished product, but he’s only 21 and doesn’t have to be rushed into an every-down role. Expect a breakout season in 2015.
Not unlike Eifert, Zach Ertz spent his rookie season in a situational role behind a veteran. Ertz did a bit more from a fantasy perspective, however, racking up four touchdowns on 36 receptions. Although his short-term ceiling is limited a bit by the Eagles spread-it-around attack and in-line usage of Brent Celek, Ertz sees enough work in a high-scoring offense to put him on the TE1 radar in 2014.
A third-round pick last season, Jordan Reed was immediately inserted as a regular contributor in the Redskins’ passing game. He racked up 45 receptions and three scores as a rookie, but did all that in only nine games due to injury. Expected to be fully recovered from the concussion that cost him the second half of the season, 23-year-old Reed will enter 2014 as a featured pass-catcher in Washington.
Ladarius Green is primed for a breakout third season following some impressive flashes in 2013. A fourth-round pick in 2012, Green had a pair of 80-yard receiving games and scored four touchdowns in 18 games last season. Primed to play a much bigger role at the expense of 34-year-old Antonio Gates, 6’6”/240 Green is the top candidate to be this year’s version of Thomas and Cameron.
The tight end-needy Jets selected Jace Amaro in the second round of May’s draft. Amaro stands at 6’5/265 and will do most of his damage as a pass-catcher. He’ll need to work on his blocking in order to hold down an every-down job, but, like Ebron, he’ll quickly become one of his team’s top receivers. The Jets will continue to lean on the run and won’t score many touchdowns, which limits Amaro’s short-term outlook. He’s only 21, however, and is a player the club will look to build its offense around.
The Minnesota offense is going the right direction, which makes Kyle Rudolph an intriguing redraft and dynasty tight end. The talented Cordarrelle Patterson/Greg Jennings duo will open up the seam for Rudolph, the selection of Teddy Bridgewater in May’s draft will improve offensive effectiveness, and the hiring of Norv Turner will guarantee plenty of involvement in the passing game. Rudolph is only 24, but already has three NFL seasons under his belt. That includes a nine-touchdown effort in 2012. He’s a decent dynasty TE1 option.
Vernon Davis was No. 2 in fantasy scoring at tight end last season. Of course, he accomplished the feat despite catching only 52 passes, which ranked 15th at the position. Davis was carried by a whopping 13 touchdowns. Although he’s heavily-used near the goal line, that touchdown rate is certain to regress in 2014 and beyond. It’s also worth noting that his targets dropped quite a bit once Michael Crabtree returned to action. Now 30, and with more competition for targets than he’s had in a long time, Davis is fading to a borderline TE1 option in dynasty.
A second-round selection in May’s draft, Austin Seferian-Jenkins has only Brandon Myers and Tim Wright standing between him and an every-down role in Tampa Bay. “ASJ” is a competent blocker and receiver, but has work to do before he reaches his ceiling. He’s big and athletic enough to produce at a TE1 level over the long term.
Dennis Pitta re-upped with the Ravens this offseason. Already a strong short-term TE1, the team’s hiring of Gary Kubiak only increases his value. Pitta missed 12 games last season due to a hip injury, but he racked up 20 catches in the four games he played. The No. 7-scoring fantasy tight end of 2012, Pitta is probably a little older than you realize at 28, but he’ll be one of Joe Flacco’s primary targets over the next few seasons.
The iron man that is Jason Witten has now failed to miss a single game each of the last 10 seasons. The veteran has four 1,000-yard seasons and 51 touchdowns during that span. Of course, Witten put up his lowest catch (73) and yardage (851) totals since 2006 this past season. From a fantasy perspective, he covered that up a bit with eight touchdowns, but the 32 year old is past his prime. He’s no longer a strong dynasty option.
Coby Fleener was forced into a larger role than anticipated last season after Dwayne Allen went down for the year with a hip injury. Fleener played well and ended up No. 14 in fantasy points at the position. He will remain heavily-involved in the Colts’ offensive gameplan, but he’s going to have a lot of competition for targets with Allen – a quality blocker and capable receiver – and Reggie Wayne back from injury, and Hakeem Nicks and Donte Moncrief now in the mix. Fleener is only 25 and a quality dynasty hold, but his short-term ceiling is that of a mid-pack TE2.
One of the league’s top blocking tight ends, Martellus Bennett has now put together back-to-back Top 15 fantasy seasons. A year after shining in New York - his first campaign as a full-time starter – Bennett finished No. 10 in fantasy points among tight ends as a member of the Bears. Bennett hauled in 65 balls for 759 yards. He scored five touchdowns, but was heavily utilized near the goal line. Still only 27, Bennett has several TE1 seasons left in the tank.
Greg Olsen went through a bizarre stretch of under-use last season, but bounced back to finish as fantasy’s No. 8 tight end. Following a five-week stretch of no more than five targets, he averaged 8.1 per game the rest of the way and was never below six in a single game. With Carolina transitioning at wide receiver, it’s fair to expect, at least, another 100-plus target season out of Olsen. He’s 29, but remains a decent short-term starting option.