These rankings were updated Friday evening
As FootballOutsiders points out, it's National Jump to Conclusions week. The Bengals offense is dead, Michael Turner is the messiah, and Marc Bulger has forever morphed into the late career Drew Bledsoe.
The question every owner must answer: How much truly changes in a week?
I was in a draft that took place Wednesday night that opened my eyes to how quickly perceptions can change. (Our annual NBC league was delayed as people got back from the Olympics, so we were forced to start late). Within today's ranking notes, I'll mention some of the draft results to highlight what players legitimately saw their value change in Week 1 (Selvin Young, Philip Rivers) and which performances were a mirage. Fantasy owners love action and transactions, but don't forget that staying the course is often our best move.
For projections of all the rankings below, head to Season Pass. I'll also be chatting there with subscribers on Friday afternoon.
Week 2 Quarterbacks
| Rank | Player Name | Opponent | Notes |
| 1 | Tony Romo | vs. PHI | - |
| 2 | Donovan McNabb | at DAL | - |
| 3 | Peyton Manning | at MIN | - |
| 4 | Ben Roethlisberger | at CLE | Will start |
| 5 | Jay Cutler | vs. SD | |
| 6 | Drew Brees | at WAS | - |
| 7 | Kurt Warner | vs. MIA | - |
| 8 | Eli Manning | at STL | - |
| 9 | Aaron Rodgers | at DET | - |
| 10 | Carson Palmer | vs. TEN | Shaky option? |
| 11 | Derek Anderson | vs. PIT | - |
| 12 | David Garrard | vs. BUF | - |
| 13 | Brett Favre | vs. NE | - |
| 14 | Philip Rivers | at DEN | Regaining mobility |
| 15 | Matt Schaub | vs. BAL | - |
| 16 | Brian Griese | vs. ATL | - |
| 17 | Matt Hasselbeck | vs. SF | - |
| 18 | Jon Kitna | vs. GB | - |
| 19 | Jake Delhomme | vs. CHI | - |
| 20 | Matt Cassel | at NYJ | - |
| 21 | Marc Bulger | vs. NYG | - |
| 22 | Jason Campbell | vs. NO | - |
| 23 | J.T. O'Sullivan | at SEA | - |
| 24 | Tarvaris Jackson | vs. IND | Probable(knee) |
| 25 | Chad Pennington | at ARZ | - |
| 26 | Trent Edwards | at JAC | - |
| 27 | Kerry Collins | at CIN | - |
| 28 | Damon Huard | vs. OAK | - |
| 29 | Kyle Orton | at CAR | - |
| 30 | JaMarcus Russell | at KC | - |
| 31 | Matt Ryan | at TB | - |
| 32 | Joe Flacco | at HOU | - |
QB Notes: Let's start with Bulger, who quarterbacked an incomparably terrible Rams offense Sunday. The play that summed up the effort for me on tape, other than the six false starts, was on a first half play in which the Rams max protected Bulger. Three Eagles landed on top of him anyway. With
Torry Holt double teamed, the Rams wideouts just didn't create any separation. In the draft last night, Bulger went
171st! This was after
Trent Edwards and
Matt Ryan. After all the good times Bulger has given fantasy owners, I felt guilty, like I should call him to apologize.
Bulger is not that bad and he should have gone way before the young guys. You can't play him this week against a strong Giants defensive line, but he's still a top-20 quarterback. … I was confident
Donovan McNabb was a top-seven quarterback all along, but it was nice to see his young receivers perform so well. The second year after ACL surgery is a beautiful thing. …
Ben Roethlisberger should play this week and he's got a great matchup. With
Sean Jones out for Cleveland, the Browns are going to struggle preventing big plays.
Jay Cutler went with the 47th pick in our draft, a leap that was understandable. With
Tom Brady out for the season, my top two tiers of quarterbacks are down to six and there is a huge drop-off after Cutler. Some of the QB options after the drop (
Vince Young,
Matt Hasselbeck,
David Garrard) have legitimate concerns, making this top six more valuable. … Garrard fell to the 114th pick, which was too far. All the offensive line injuries will hurt the Jaguars, but they are strong enough to stay solid. I expect all the injuries to effect the running game more.
One player whose season-long value
did change in Week 1 was
Philip Rivers. I didn't expect him to look so strong coming off ACL surgery. It wasn't just his numbers, but his amazing movement and confidence in the pocket. The pass rush didn't bother him. In fact, he avoided many hits and threw on the run. He still must prove he can be consistent (a problem in the past), but I'm far less concerned about his post-surgery accuracy. He was far more comfortable than
Carson Palmer,
Daunte Culpepper, or
Donovan McNabb after their surgery.
Matt Hasselbeck's value is legitimately lower than it was a week ago. Until the team has
Bobby Engram and
Deion Branch back, he'll do well to be a solid QB2. He's a matchup play.
Some players I wouldn't jump to conclusions on:
Carson Palmer: The Ravens will make a lot of quarterbacks look terrible Unfortunately, so will the Titans.
Jake Delhomme: It was very surprising to see the Panthers go so pass-wacky. But Delhomme was still erratic for much of the game.
Derek Anderson: The concern here is that the Browns defense will keep losing games, and Brady Quinn chants will start. But D.A. will bounce back because of the weapons around him.
Matt Schaub: Like Carson Palmer, he faces a brutal early start. But he's still a long-term QB1/2. 25-of-33 for 202 yards, one touchdown, and two interceptions are the stats you want when a quarterback struggles.
Continue story ...
| |
Gregg Rosenthal is the Managing Editor of Rotoworld.com and has directed its football content since 2003. He co-hosts the NBC Fantasy Fix and covers the NFL for NBCSports.com and Profootballtalk.com. Catch him on Twitter. |
Contact Gregg Rosenthal
|
| |