Rotoworld Staff

Premium Content

Goalie Outliers

Thursday, August 31, 2017

The rankings you will find in these pages are an average. We took the ranks of Michael Finewax, Brian Rosenbaum, Ryan Dadoun and Corey Abbott to formulate a composite score. Of course, there was no way we were all going to agree on every player. Some of us had unique feelings on certain guys, making them outliers. Here are the right winger rankings and explanations:


Goalie Rankings


1 Devan Dubnyk Carey Price Carey Price Braden Holtby
2 Sergei Bobrovsky Matt Murray Braden Holtby Sergei Bobrovsky
3 Braden Holtby Braden Holtby Sergei Bobrovsky Carey Price
4 Carey Price Devan Dubnyk Devan Dubnyk Matt Murray
5 Cam Talbot Cam Talbot Cam Talbot Devan Dubnyk
6 Jonathan Quick Pekka Rinne Jonathan Quick Cam Talbot
7 Tuukka Rask Corey Crawford Matt Murray Tuukka Rask
8 Jake Allen Sergei Bobrovsky Tuukka Rask Jonathan Quick
9 Matt Murray Jake Allen Pekka Rinne Jake Allen
10 Andrei Vasilevskiy Jonathan Quick Corey Crawford John Gibson
11 Craig Anderson Tuukka Rask John Gibson Pekka Rinne
12 Corey Crawford John Gibson Martin Jones Ben Bishop
13 Henrik Lundqvist Andrei Vasilevskiy Andrei Vasilevskiy Andrei Vasilevskiy
14 John Gibson Henrik Lundqvist Jake Allen Craig Anderson
15 Pekka Rinne Martin Jones Craig Anderson Corey Crawford
16 Frederik Andersen Craig Anderson Henrik Lundqvist Henrik Lundqvist
17 Martin Jones Ben Bishop Frederik Andersen Frederik Andersen
18 Ben Bishop Frederik Andersen Ben Bishop Martin Jones
19 Mike Smith Robin Lehner Mike Smith Mike Smith
20 Roberto Luongo Steve Mason Roberto Luongo Roberto Luongo
21 Brian Elliott Mike Smith Scott Darling Brian Elliott
22 Scott Darling Brian Elliott Brian Elliott Cory Schneider
23 Robin Lehner Jimmy Howard Robin Lehner Robin Lehner
24 Cory Schneider Cory Schneider Cory Schneider Scott Darling
25 Jacob Markstrom Roberto Luongo Antti Raanta Antti Raanta
26 Antti Raanta Jaroslav Halak Jaroslav Halak Jacob Markstrom
27 Jaroslav Halak Scott Darling Steve Mason Thomas Greiss
28 Steve Mason Jacob Markstrom Semyon Varlamov Jaroslav Halak
29 Petr Mrazek Marc-Andre Fleury Marc-Andre Fleury Steve Mason
30 Semyon Varlamov Semyon Varlamov Jacob Markstrom Marc-Andre Fleury
31 Marc-Andre Fleury Antti Raanta Jimmy Howard Petr Mrazek
32 Jimmy Howard James Reimer Thomas Greiss Jimmy Howard
33 Thomas Greiss Connor Hellebuyck Petr Mrazek Semyon Varlamov
34 Philipp Grubauer Petr Mrazek Michal Neuvirth James Reimer
35 Peter Budaj Ryan Miller Philipp Grubauer Philipp Grubauer
36 James Reimer Michal Neuvirth Peter Budaj Peter Budaj
37 Connor Hellebuyck Thomas Greiss James Reimer Chad Johnson
38 Ryan Miller Anders Nilsson Ryan Miller Cam Ward
39 Cam Ward Cam Ward Connor Hellebuyck Ryan Miller
40 Anton Forsberg Philipp Grubauer Cam Ward Kari Lehtonen


Michael Finewax had Devan Dubnyk first. The average draft composite was 4.5.


Devan Dubnyk was the best goalie in the NHL last season for the first 50 games. Both he and the Wild faltered after that, but the Wild are going to be stronger this season and don't have a reliable backup netminder. Dubnyk will carry the Wild to first in their division and I think he will win the Vezina.


Corey Abbott had Ben Bishop 12. The average draft composite was 16.25.


Ben Bishop had to contend with trade rumors, an expiring contract and an oncoming Andrei Vasilevskiy last season. He will get back to being the number one goalie with Dallas this year. The Stars should boast a dangerous offense and the defense should benefit from having Ken Hitchcock behind the bench.  Bishop is being placed in a great position to add to what has been an impressive résumé.  He has collected 130 wins since the 2013-14 season, which ranks him fourth overall. Bishop also has a .920 save percentage and a 2.26 goals-against average during that span.